When you pick a health, auto or home policy, you’re often choosing between two kinds of plans: one with a higher monthly premium and a low deductible, and one with a lower premium and a high deductible. The cheaper monthly price is tempting, but it isn’t always the cheaper plan.

This guide explains how premiums and deductibles work together, when each kind of plan tends to come out ahead and how to compare your own options with our free Premium & Deductible Comparison.

The Terms In Plain English

  • Premium: what you pay every month to keep the coverage, whether you use it or not.
  • Deductible: what you pay toward covered costs each year before the insurance starts sharing the bill.
  • Coinsurance: your share of costs after the deductible, such as 20%.
  • Out-of-pocket maximum: the most you’d pay in a year for covered costs. After that, the plan pays 100%.

Your real yearly cost is your premiums plus what you pay when you use the coverage.

Low Premium Or Low Deductible?

A high deductible plan usually has lower premiums, so it costs less in a year when you don’t use much care. A low deductible plan costs more each month, but you pay less when something happens. The right choice depends on how much you expect to use your coverage, and how well you could handle a large bill.

Loading Premium & Deductible Comparison…

A Worked Example: Plan B Saves About $200

Say you’re comparing two plans:

  • Plan A: $450 a month, a $1,000 deductible, 20% coinsurance and a $4,000 out-of-pocket maximum.
  • Plan B: $300 a month, a $4,000 deductible, 20% coinsurance and a $7,000 out-of-pocket maximum.

You expect about $3,000 in covered care this year. Plan A would cost about $6,800 for the year ($5,400 in premiums plus $1,400 in care). Plan B would cost about $6,600 ($3,600 in premiums plus $3,000 in care). Plan B saves about $200.

The answer changes with your year:

  • No claims at all: Plan B saves $1,800, since you only pay premiums.
  • A very expensive year: Plan A saves $1,200, because its out-of-pocket maximum is lower.
  • The tipping point: at about $3,250 in covered care, the two plans cost the same. Expect less, and Plan B tends to win; expect more, and Plan A does.

Questions To Ask Before You Choose

  1. How much care did I use last year? Past costs are a reasonable starting estimate.
  2. Could I pay the full deductible tomorrow? If not, a lower deductible may be safer, even if it costs a little more.
  3. Is anything planned? A surgery, a baby or a known repair can push you toward the lower deductible.
  4. Does my employer add money? Some high deductible health plans come with an HSA, and employer contributions can change the math. The Health Plan Cost Comparison handles copays, prescriptions and HSA money.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does This Work For Auto And Home Insurance Too?

Yes, the same trade-off applies. With auto and home policies, the deductible is what you pay per claim, so think about how likely a claim is and how much you could cover from savings.

What If I Have No Idea What My Costs Will Be?

Look at the no-claims and worst-case results together. If you could handle the worst case, the lower premium may make sense. If a big bill would be a hardship, the lower deductible adds peace of mind.

Should I Keep Savings For My Deductible?

It’s a good idea, especially with a high deductible plan. Our Emergency Fund Calculator can help you set a target that covers it.

The Bottom Line

The cheapest premium isn’t always the cheapest plan. Comparing your total yearly cost across a light year, your expected year and a worst-case year shows which plan fits your life. Try the Premium & Deductible Comparison with the plans you’re considering.

This article is for education only and isn’t insurance advice. Check each plan’s documents for exact costs and rules.