Open enrollment often comes down to two health plans: one with copays and a lower deductible, and a high-deductible plan with a cheaper premium and maybe an HSA. Comparing premiums alone can point you to the wrong choice.

This guide shows how to estimate a full year of costs under each plan, based on how you actually use care, and how our free Health Plan Cost Comparison does the math.

What Goes Into Your Real Health Plan Cost

  • Premiums: your share, taken from each paycheck.
  • Copays: a flat fee for visits or prescriptions on some plans.
  • Deductible: what you pay for covered care before the plan starts sharing costs.
  • Coinsurance: your share after the deductible.
  • Out-of-pocket maximum: the most you’d pay for covered care in a year.
  • Employer HSA or HRA money: dollars your employer adds, which lower your real cost.

Your yearly cost is premiums plus what you pay for care, minus any employer money.

Start With How You Use Care

Think about a typical year: how many doctor visits, how many prescriptions each month and any tests, procedures or ER visits you expect. Last year’s bills and statements are a good guide. The comparison then shows three pictures: the year you expect, a light year and a year where you hit the out-of-pocket maximum.

Loading Health Plan Cost Comparison…

A Worked Example: Plan B Saves About $870

Say you’re comparing:

  • Plan A (copay plan): $220 a month, a $1,500 deductible, 20% coinsurance, a $5,000 out-of-pocket maximum, $30 doctor visits and $15 prescriptions.
  • Plan B (HSA-eligible plan): $120 a month, a $3,500 deductible, 10% coinsurance, a $6,500 out-of-pocket maximum, no copays, and $750 a year from your employer into an HSA.

You expect 6 doctor visits (about $160 each), one prescription a month (about $40) and $1,200 in other covered care.

  • Plan A would cost about $4,200: $2,640 in premiums, $360 in copays and $1,200 toward the deductible.
  • Plan B would cost about $3,330: $1,440 in premiums plus $2,640 in care, minus the $750 from your employer.

Plan B saves about $870 in the year you expect. In a light year, it saves about $1,820. Even in a year when you hit the out-of-pocket maximum, it saves about $450, thanks to the lower premium and employer money.

Questions To Ask Before You Enroll

  1. Could I cover the higher deductible? With Plan B, you’d pay the full price of care until you reach $3,500.
  2. Are my doctors and prescriptions covered? Check each plan’s network and drug list.
  3. Is anything big coming up? A planned surgery or new baby can change which plan comes out ahead.
  4. Would I use an HSA? HSA money can be saved and invested for future medical costs, which adds value the comparison doesn’t count.

Frequently Asked Questions

What Is An HSA?

A health savings account lets people with an HSA-eligible, high-deductible plan set money aside for medical costs. It has tax advantages, and unused money rolls over from year to year.

Why Do Copays Count Differently?

On a copay plan, visits and prescriptions often cost a flat fee instead of going toward the deductible. On many high-deductible plans, you pay the full price until you meet the deductible.

Does This Include Out-Of-Network Care?

No. The comparison uses in-network costs only. Out-of-network care usually costs more and may not count toward the same limits.

The Bottom Line

The plan with the lower premium isn’t always cheaper, and neither is the plan with copays. Estimating a full year, including employer money, shows the real difference. Try the Health Plan Cost Comparison before your next open enrollment, and see our guide to the Premium & Deductible Comparison for a simpler side-by-side.

This article is for education only and isn’t insurance or medical advice. Check each plan’s summary of benefits and coverage for exact costs.